Chapter 14 - The Deposition

The air inside the fifth-floor deposition room at the Cook County Legal Center was thick with cold tension. Fluorescent lights hummed overhead, casting a harsh glare on the long mahogany table.
On one side sat Richard and Eleanor Vance, flanked by Arthur Pendelton and three senior litigation partners. Richard Vance was a broad-shouldered man in his late sixties with silver hair, cold blue eyes, and a face carved from stone. Eleanor sat beside him, dressed in an expensive black wool suit, her expression locked in a mask of bitter, distant grief.
Across from them sat Evan, Marcus, and myself.
This was the first time Evan had sat in the same room as Rowan's parents in over five years. Richard refused to look Evan in the eye, treating him with the absolute dismissal one might reserve for a stranger.
"We are on the record," the court reporter announced, her fingers hovering over her machine. "Deposition of Dr. Evelyn Rao and Mr. Evan Vance in the matter of Vance v. Vance."
Arthur Pendelton leaned forward, adjusting his gold cufflinks. He directed his gaze at Evan.
"Mr. Vance," Pendelton began, his voice dropping into a smooth, practiced cadence. "Isn't it true that during the third trimester of your late wife’s pregnancy, you were facing severe financial hardship due to the downturn in your architectural practice?"
"Objection; relevance," Marcus cut in sharply.
"It establishes motive, Your Honor—or rather, counsel," Pendelton corrected smoothly. "I will rephrase. Mr. Vance, were you aware of the terms of the Vance Family Trust established by Rowan's late grandfather prior to her admission to St. Jude Hospital?"
Evan looked directly at Richard Vance before answering. "I was not. Rowan never discussed her grandfather's trust with me. We built our life on our own earnings."
"A compelling narrative," Pendelton sneered softly. "Yet, when your wife fell into a comatose state in the ICU, you consistently refused to allow her wealthy, capable parents to provide private medical care or transfer her to a specialized facility in Chicago. Why? Was it because transferring her would have removed you as the primary healthcare proxy?"
"Objection!" Marcus shouted, slamming his hand on the table. "Counsel is badgering the witness and asserting facts not in evidence!"
"I refused to transfer her," Evan said, his voice rising with absolute clarity, ignoring Marcus's motion to remain silent, "because moving a woman in acute heart failure on full life support would have killed both her and her unborn child within minutes. Dr. Rao told us that. The ethics board agreed. Rowan told me herself, before she lost consciousness, that she wanted her baby saved at all costs."
"And do you have a written, notarized document from your wife specifically stating she wanted to risk her life for this child?" Pendelton pressed aggressively. "Or do we only have your word—the word of a man who stood to gain control of a fourteen-million-dollar trust upon her death?"
Eleanor Vance let out a faint, quiet sniffle, pressing a lace handkerchief to her nose for the benefit of the video camera recording the proceedings.
Before Marcus could object again, the door to the deposition room opened.
Dr. Rao walked in, wearing his white lab coat, carrying a battered leather briefcase. He didn't look at the lawyers. He walked straight to the witness chair, sat down, and placed a small electronic recording device on the center of the table.
"What is the meaning of this?" Pendelton demanded, startled by the doctor's sudden entry.
"This is an official medical record," Dr. Rao said calmly, adjusting his glasses. "Three days before Rowan Vance suffered her acute cardiac event, she came into my clinic for a routine high-risk screening. She knew her heart was under severe strain. She asked me to record an audio file on her patient portal, to be attached to her living will in the event she became incapacitated."
The room went dead silent. Richard Vance’s cold eyes snapped up, staring at the small black recorder on the table.
Dr. Rao pressed play.
The room filled with the soft, clear, unmistakable sound of Rowan’s voice.
"This is Rowan Vance. Today is October 14th. I am making this recording with Dr. Rao because I know my pregnancy carries extreme risk. I want it clearly understood by my doctors, my family, and any legal entity: Evan is my voice. If a moment comes where a choice must be made, my husband has my absolute, unreserved authority to protect our child. To my parents, if you are listening to this... I forgave you long ago for walking away from me. But this child is my choice. Evan is my family. Do not fight him. Let my baby live."
The recording stopped. The static hiss of the audio file lingered in the quiet room like a physical presence.
Eleanor Vance bowed her head, her shoulders shaking violently as real tears finally broke through her frozen composure. Richard Vance turned pale, his jaw clenching so hard a muscle twitched in his cheek.
Evan sat motionless, tears streaming down his face, hearing his wife's voice defending him from beyond the grave.
May you like
Marcus looked across the table at Pendelton and Richard Vance, his voice dropping into a quiet, lethal decree.
"Gentlemen," Marcus said softly. "I suggest you withdraw your petition before we play this tape in open court on Wednesday morning."