Chapter 3 - The Deposition of Denise Dawson
The conference room on the thirty-fourth floor of the Sterling & Associates law firm looked out over the frozen expanse of the Grand Rapids skyline. The room was sterile, modern, and silent, save for the rhythmic humming of the video recording equipment set up in the corner.
Across the long mahogany table sat my mother, Denise Dawson.
She was flanked by a court-appointed public defender named Mr. Henderson—a tired-looking man in a wrinkled gray suit who clearly looked like he wanted to be anywhere else in the world. My mother’s hands trembled violently as she adjusted her cheap reading glasses, staring at the thick stack of evidence folders sitting directly in front of Marcus Sterling.
I sat beside Marcus, dressed in a sharp navy blazer, my face an emotionless mask.
"This is the formal civil deposition of Denise Dawson," Marcus announced clearly into the microphone. "In the matter of Rachel Dawson v. Denise Dawson, Grant Dawson, and Lauren Dawson, Case Number 2026-CV-08912. Mrs. Dawson, please state your full name for the record."
My mother swallowed hard, her voice barely above a whisper. "Denise Marie Dawson."
"Mrs. Dawson," Marcus began, pulling the first document from his file. "On November 14th of this year, you were traveling with your husband, your son Grant, your daughter-in-law Lauren, your two granddaughters, and your granddaughter Emma Dawson. Is that correct?"
"Yes," she whispered.
"Who paid for the airfare, the luxury hotel accommodations in San Diego, the rental vehicles, and the dining expenses for this entire trip?"
My mother glanced nervously at her public defender, who simply sighed and gestured for her to answer.
"Rachel paid for it," she admitted, staring down at her fingernails.
"And did Rachel explicitly ask you and your son to look after Emma during the flight from Denver to San Diego while she attended an executive security conference in Minneapolis?"
"She... she assumed we would," my mother stammered. "We were all going to the same place."
Marcus pulled a laminated sheet of paper from the stack. "I am showing you Exhibit C—a printed transcript of a text message conversation between you and Rachel on November 12th. On that date, you texted Rachel, quote: 'Don't worry about Emma on the plane, sweetie. Richard and I will keep her right beside us the whole time. Just focus on your work.' Did you send that text message?"
My mother’s cheeks flushed a bright, guilty red. "I... I suppose I did."
"So you explicitly accepted legal and moral custody of Emma for the duration of that travel segment?"
"We were family!" my mother suddenly burst out, slamming her palm onto the mahogany table. "Why are you treating this like a corporate contract?! We got to the gate, and the airline offered us five first-class upgrades! Five! They were magnificent seats! Full lay-flat beds, free champagne, priority boarding! Grant and Lauren have had such a stressful year—they deserved a break! My husband has back pain! Why should we have given up those seats?!"
Marcus didn't flinch. He simply waited for her emotional outburst to end before asking his next question with devastating composure.
"There were six people in your party, correct?"
"Yes."
"And five upgrades."
"Yes!"
"Which meant one person would have to remain in economy class with nine-year-old Emma, or the group would have to decline the upgrades altogether so you could all sit together as planned."
My mother remained silent, breathing heavily.
"Mrs. Dawson," Marcus continued softly. "Why didn't you decline the upgrades?"
"It was a promotional offer!" she yelled, her defense crumbling into pure, unadulterated selfishness. "It would have been a waste to turn it down!"
"Why didn't your son Grant remain in economy with Emma?"
"Grant was tired!"
"Why didn't your daughter-in-law Lauren remain in economy with Emma?"
"Lauren was taking care of her own two daughters in the first-class cabin!"
"So," Marcus leaned forward, his voice cutting like a razor through the quiet room, "the five adults present unanimously decided to leave a nine-year-old child sitting on a metal bench outside Gate B19, unattended, in an airport processing thirty thousand passengers an hour, so that you could drink champagne in first class."
"We told the gate agent someone would watch her!" my mother cried out, tears spilling down her wrinkled cheeks. "We knew Rachel had money! We knew she had an executive travel account! We knew if Emma was left behind, Rachel would just buy her another ticket or hire a private escort! Rachel always handles things! She always has money!"
I leaned forward, resting my elbows on the table, fixing my mother with an unwavering gaze.
"Denise," I said, speaking directly to her for the first time during the deposition. "Do you know what Emma said to me on the video call while she was sitting on that bench?"
My mother bit her trembling lip, refusing to look at me.
"She asked me if she was left behind because she did something wrong," I said, my voice dropping to a low, intense whisper that filled the entire conference room. "She thought her grandmother didn't love her because she wasn't good enough for first class."
My mother let out a strangled sob, covering her face with her trembling hands.
"You didn't just abandon my child," I said. "You tried to break her spirit so you could enjoy three hours of luxury that I paid for. You thought my love for my daughter was a safety net you could exploit forever."
May you like
Mr. Henderson, the public defender, reached over and touched my mother's arm. "We're taking a fifteen-minute recess," he said quietly, looking at Marcus with complete resignation. "My client needs a moment."
"Take all the time you need, Mr. Henderson," Marcus said, closing his file. "Because when we resume, we will be discussing the criminal indictment papers filed by the State of California."
