Chapter 4 - The Deposition of Lies
Two weeks later, the preliminary hearing convened at the County Courthouse.
The courtroom was packed with townspeople, reporters, and members of the Vance family. Eleanor sat in the front row on the defense side, wearing a black lace dress as if attending a funeral, surrounded by Brenda and a crying Lily.
Harlan sat at the defense table in a tailored gray suit, looking rested and arrogant. He had posted his fifty-thousand-dollar bail within forty-eight hours and believed his legal team had constructed an airtight defense.
The District Attorney, a sharp, unyielding woman named Sarah Jenkins, called her first witness to the stand: Dr. Aris Thorne, the pediatric surgeon who treated Noah on the night of the blizzard.
"Dr. Thorne," DA Jenkins asked, standing near the jury box. "Can you describe the condition of Noah Vance when he arrived at the emergency room?"
"Noah was suffering from late-stage second-degree frostbite on both hands and feet," Dr. Thorne testified, his voice professional and grave. "His core body temperature was ninety-three degrees. If he had remained on that porch for another thirty minutes, he would have suffered severe hypothermia leading to cardiac arrest or permanent loss of his fingers."
A collective gasp echoed through the gallery. Eleanor covered her face, weeping loudly for the benefit of the crowd.
Next, DA Jenkins called me to the stand.
I walked to the witness box, swore the oath, and sat down. My eyes locked onto Harlan. He stared back at me, offering a subtle, mocking smirk—the look of a patriarch who believed he was untouchable.
"Mrs. Vance," DA Jenkins said warmly. "Please walk us through what happened when you viewed the porch camera recordings."
I explained everything—the initial alarm, finding Noah at the hospital, and discovering the hidden administrative access to Harlan's security app.
Then, DA Jenkins pressed play on the courtroom's large monitor, broadcasting the video and audio of Lily's confession and Harlan's callous response for the judge and jury to see.
Harlan’s lead defense attorney, a sleek city lawyer named Vance Croft, immediately stood up.
"Objection, Your Honor!" Croft shouted. "This video footage was obtained without my client's knowledge or consent! It constitutes an illegal invasion of privacy and unauthorized access to a private server!"
"Your Honor," DA Jenkins countered calmly. "Mrs. Vance was given administrative credentials by the defendant himself months prior to assist with technical maintenance. She had legal authorization to access the server."
"Overruled," Judge Vance declared, slamming his gavel down. "The evidence is admissible."
Croft sneered, turning his attention to me during cross-examination. He walked toward the witness box like a wolf eyeing its prey.
"Mrs. Vance," Croft began, leaning over the wooden railing. "Isn't it true that you have maintained a hostile relationship with my client, Harlan Vance, for years?"
"I have disagreed with his abusive treatment of his family, yes," I replied coolly.
"Aha!" Croft shouted, turning to the jury. "So you admit you harbor animosity toward him! Isn't it true that you edited these audio clips using simple online software to make a harmless discipline incident sound like something malicious?"
"No," I answered smoothly. "And if you check the digital forensic report submitted by the state police cyber unit, you'll see the metadata confirms the files are raw, unedited, and timestamped in real-time."
Croft’s smile vanished. He glanced back at Harlan, whose face was beginning to turn a dangerous shade of crimson.
"Furthermore, Mr. Croft," I added, leaning forward so my voice carried through the silent courtroom, "if you are concerned about digital records, I have also submitted three years of security footage showing Mr. Harlan Vance regularly locking his family members out on the porch as a form of psychological punishment."
The courtroom erupted into loud murmurs. Judge Vance banged his gavel repeatedly.
"Order! Order in this court!"
Harlan suddenly stood up from his chair, his face contorted in rage as he bellowed across the room, "She’s a lying little bitch! I built this town! You can't do this to me!"
"Sit down, Mr. Vance!" Judge Vance shouted.
"No!" Harlan screamed, striking Marcus’s arm away as his lawyer tried to pull him down. "I should have left that brat out there all night! He’s weak, just like his damn mother!"
May you like
The entire gallery went dead silent.
Harlan stood there, panting heavily, realizing too late that he had just confessed his utter lack of remorse in front of the judge, the jury, and six local newspaper reporters.
