Chapter 6 - The Discovery Process
The office of the State Attorney’s Special Victims Unit didn't look like Arthur’s high-rise office with its mahogany paneling and views of the bay. It was a low-ceilinged room filled with the clatter of old keyboards, green hanging file folders, and a coffee machine that had been burning the same pot since Thursday.
Detective Miller was already there, sitting across from a tall, broad-shouldered man named Investigator Dave Reynolds—the man whose son had survived that Christmas Eve surgery. He looked up when I walked in with Sarah, his tired face instantly softening into a look of deep, professional respect.
"Dr. Linwood," Dave said, standing up and pulling two folding chairs forward. "The hospital transmission came through an hour ago. We’ve already reviewed the preliminary radiology data. Detective Miller gave me the breakdown on what happened at the ER."
"This is my daughter, Sarah," I said, positioning her in the chair beside mine. "She’s ready to make a formal statement. Not just about last night. About the last two years."
For the next three hours, the room was silent except for the sound of Sarah’s voice and the rhythmic tapping of Detective Miller’s fingers on her laptop. Sarah told them everything. She told them about the safe in the master bedroom where Arthur kept the scheduled narcotics; she told them about the logbooks he kept listing every time she begged him for a dose; she told them about the bruises Maya had hidden under her soccer uniforms.
But the real turning point came when Dave Reynolds pulled a heavy yellow envelope from his desk drawer.
"While you were on your way here, Doctor, we executed an emergency digital search warrant on Arthur Finch’s firm profile," Dave said, sliding a stack of printed emails across the table. "Because he used his firm’s encrypted email server to send threats to your hospital’s chief of staff this morning, he waived his private privilege regarding those communications under the state's corporate crime statutes."
I picked up the papers. My eyes scanned the text, the coldness inside me turning into something absolute and solid.
Arthur hadn't just been threatening the hospital. He had been planning to liquidate Sarah’s private dermatology practice’s medical equipment and real estate assets through a dummy corporation registered in Delaware—a transfer that was scheduled to take effect on Monday morning at 9:00 a.m. He had forged her signature on the transfer deeds using a power of attorney he had forced her to sign during her relapse six months ago.
"He was going to strip her clean," Dave said, his jaw tight. "He knew the abuse was going to get out eventually. He was just waiting until he had transferred all her personal wealth out of her name so that when the divorce happened, she wouldn't have the financial resources to hire a proper defense."
May you like
"The recording Maya made," Sarah whispered, her face pale. "Is it legal? Can we use it?"
Dave looked at me, then back at Sarah. "The recording captured him stating that he would 'break her other arm' if she didn't tell the paramedics what he wanted. Under Florida Statute 934.03, the single-party exception applies when there is a reasonable belief that a violent felony involving physical force is about to be repeated. Your daughter didn't just save herself last night, Sarah. She handed us the key to his cell door."
