Chapter 2 - The Ashes of Bennett Street
Within fifteen minutes, the wailing sirens of the Bennett Street Volunteer Fire Department shattered the evening silence. Red and blue emergency lights flashed against the manicured hedges and white picket fences of the neighborhood, drawing curious neighbors out onto their porches in their bathrobes and slippers.
Mrs. Higgins, who lived across the street and had spent twenty years praising Eleanor Monroe as the "model mother of the county," stood near the edge of the driveway, wringing her hands.
"Oh, Eleanor, you poor thing!" Mrs. Higgins cried, rushing over to pat Eleanor’s arm. "Such a tragedy! And poor little Caitlyn, always getting into such dangerous mischief. I told my husband just last week, that child has a reckless streak unlike anyone in this family."
Eleanor pressed a lace handkerchief to her dry eyes, letting out a delicate, theatrical shudder. "Thank you, Martha. It’s just... it’s been so hard since her father passed. I try to keep her safe, I really do, but she fights me at every turn. She locked herself in, you see. I was downstairs making tea when I smelled the smoke."
Arthur stepped forward, his face flushed with a dark, dangerous rage. He looked like a storm about to break.
"She didn't lock herself in, Martha!" Arthur shouted, pointing a trembling finger right at his sister-in-law. "I had to kick that door off its hinges! The latch was turned from the outside! Eleanor had that little girl bolted inside while the fire started!"
The neighborhood gossips went dead silent. Heads snapped toward Arthur, then toward Eleanor, whose pale face tightened into a mask of righteous offense.
"Arthur, please," Eleanor whispered, her voice trembling with calculated vulnerability. "We are all shaken up. You’ve always had a bias against my parenting style, but to accuse me of... of trying to harm my own flesh and blood? In front of our neighbors?"
"You lying snake," Arthur muttered, balling his hands into fists.
Before Arthur could lunge forward, the lead firefighter, Captain Vance, walked down the driveway with a heavy, soot-covered helmet tucked under his arm. He looked at Eleanor, then at Arthur, and finally down at seven-year-old Caitlyn, who was sitting quietly on the bumper of Arthur’s truck, wrapped in a heavy wool blanket.
"Ma'am," Captain Vance said, his tone flat and professional. "We checked the origin point of the fire. It started directly inside the bedroom closet, fueled by old cotton linens. But the door mechanism... well, my boys had to use a crowbar from the hallway side. The deadbolt latch was thrown from the outside corridor. Someone slid the brass bolt home."
Eleanor didn't blink. "Well, Caitlyn has a habit of tampering with hardware when she throws her tantrums. She must have rigged it from the inside."
"With a keyhole on the outside?" Arthur barked. "Since when do kids' bedroom doors have keyed deadbolts installed on the outside?"
Captain Vance’s eyes narrowed slightly. He flipped open his metal clipboard. "We'll need to conduct a formal origin-and-cause investigation, Mrs. Monroe. In the meantime, social services will need to place the minor in a secure, neutral environment until the safety inspection is cleared."
Eleanor’s facade finally slipped for a fraction of a second—just a twitch of her left eye, a sudden tightening of her jaw. "That won't be necessary, Captain. Caitlyn will be staying with my sister in Ohio starting tomorrow morning."
May you like
"No, she won't," Arthur said, stepping between Eleanor and the firefighter. "She’s coming home with me. And she’s bringing her things."
Caitlyn looked down at the old brown boot sitting on the floorboard of Arthur’s truck. Inside it, hidden away from prying eyes, was the ledger of secrets her mother had tried so hard to burn.
