Chapter 7 - The Deposition Threat

By Monday morning, the legal legal gears were turning with relentless force.
Arthur Vance called my phone at 10:00 AM.
"Rachel, I just got off the phone with Diane’s attorney, Mr. Harrison," Arthur said, his tone carrying a note of professional triumph. "It seems he was entirely unaware of the bank statements and the text message history when he took your mother’s case."
"He didn't know?" I asked.
"Your mother framed the situation to him as a tragic story of a neglected elderly mother whose ungrateful daughter suddenly abandoned her and stopped sending agreed-upon support," Arthur explained. "When I emailed him the copy of our Motion to Dismiss—complete with the thirty-six monthly wire receipts, your text logs, and Melissa’s signed affidavit confirming the Thanksgiving incident—Mr. Harrison sounded like a man who had just realized he was standing on a landmine."
I let out a breath I didn't realize I was holding. "What did he say?"
"He asked for a seventy-two-hour stay on all filings so he could 'confer with his client,'" Arthur chuckled. "Translating from lawyer-speak: he is currently telling your mother that if she proceeds with this lawsuit, she is going to be slaughtered in court."
"Will she drop it?"
"If she has a shred of legal sanity left, yes," Arthur said. "However, given her personality profile, she may still push back out of sheer narcissism. To ensure we drive the point home, I have formally scheduled a Notice of Deposition for Diane for next Thursday at my office."
My heart did a quick flutter. "A deposition? She’ll have to testify under oath?"
"Under oath, on video, with a court reporter present," Arthur confirmed. "I will spend four hours grilling her on her income, her private bank accounts, her life insurance payout, her tax returns, and the exact verbiage she used when demanding money from you. If she lies under oath, it’s perjury—a felony. If she tells the truth, she admits to fraud. Either way, she loses."
The notice of deposition was served to Diane on Tuesday afternoon.
The reaction was immediate and seismic.
At 4:00 PM, my phone rang. It was an unfamiliar number with a Columbus area code. I answered cautiously.
"Rachel?"
It was Uncle Mark. His voice sounded weary, aged ten years in the span of three weeks.
"Uncle Mark," I said coolly. "I thought you weren't talking to me."
"Rachel, please, don't hang up," he said quickly. "I'm not calling to lecture you. I'm calling because... I just left your mother's house. Her lawyer told her today that she needs to settle this immediately and drop the suit before the deposition next week."
"Then she should listen to her lawyer," I said.
"She’s in a terrifying state, Rachel," Uncle Mark said, his voice dropping to a humbled whisper. "She’s pacing the floor, talking about how everyone turned on her, how you ruined her life. She’s refusing to eat. She... she realized today that if she goes to that deposition, her financial records will become public record. Everyone in our town, her church, her social clubs—they'll all know what she did."
"She should have thought about that before she served me with a lawsuit, Uncle Mark," I said coldly. "She tried to drag my twelve-year-old daughter into court. She tried to ruin my family financially and emotionally. I am not going to feel guilty because her own lies caught up to her."
There was a long silence on the line. When Uncle Mark spoke again, his voice was cracked with emotion.
"I sat at that Thanksgiving table, Rachel," he said softly. "I laughed when she made that joke about Lily. I thought it was just Diane being Diane... her usual sharp, sarcastic self. I didn't think about how it felt to be that little girl standing in the corner. I was wrong. I was an idiot, and I was a coward for not speaking up."
I squeezed my eyes shut, feeling a lump form in my throat. Hearing my uncle—a man who had always been the proud, stoic patriarch of our extended family—admit his failure was overwhelming.
"Why didn't you stop her?" I asked, my voice cracking slightly. "You knew Lily was quiet. You knew Mom treated her differently."
"Because Diane has controlled this family since your dad died," Uncle Mark confessed. "She made us all feel like we owed her something. She made us believe she was fragile, that one wrong word would shatter her. So we all walked on eggshells, humored her cruelty, and let her walk over anyone she wanted—as long as it wasn't us. But seeing what she did to you—and finding out she was stealing your money while lying to us—it broke the spell, Rachel."
"I'm not dropping the counterclaim until she signs a full legal surrender, Uncle Mark," I said firmly. "She drops the lawsuit, she waives all rights to ever seek visitation, and she signs a non-disparagement agreement promising to never post about us on social media or speak about Lily again. Otherwise, we go to the deposition on Thursday."
"She’ll sign it," Uncle Mark said without hesitation. "I will personally take the papers to her house and force her to sign them. She has no fight left, Rachel. You broke her control over this family."
After hanging up, I went into the kitchen where Mark was preparing dinner. I leaned against his shoulder, letting out a long, shuddering sigh.
"Uncle Mark called," I told him. "It’s almost over."
Mark wrapped his arm around my waist, pulling me close. "She’s backing down?"
"She has to," I said. "For thirty years, she used shame as a weapon against us. But the second we threw the light of truth on her, her weapon evaporated. Shame only works if you're willing to stay silent to protect the bully."
May you like
"And we're never being silent again," Mark said.
"Never," I agreed.