Chapter 5 - The Midnight Audit
The scent of burning paper and pine resin was thick in the freezing night air long before they reached the bottom of Oak Street.
Two fire engines from the volunteer department were parked across the front of Harrow’s Market, their red warning lights painting the snow-draped storefront in rhythmic crimson flashes. Firemen in heavy coats were dragging yellow hoses through the shattered glass front doors, while a small crowd of townspeople stood behind the yellow police tape, their faces lit by the firelight and the glare of news vans that had driven up from the valley below.
Caspian stepped out of his SUV, Arthur and two security officers at his flanks.
“Where’s Pike?” Caspian asked, walking directly up to Officer Vance, who was standing near the pump truck.
“Inside,” Vance said, pointing toward the rear of the building where smoke was billowing through a broken second-story window. “He locked himself in the manager’s office when he saw my cruiser coming back down the hill. He set fire to the filing cabinets before the boys could kick the back door down. They got him out, but he’s fighting like a wildcat.”
A moment later, two tall deputies hauled a man out through the scorched front doors. Gideon Pike was covered in black soot, his hair singed at the temples, his flannel shirt torn at the collar. He was screaming curses at the crowd, his eyes wild and bloodshot in the red light of the emergency beacons.
“It’s my store!” Gideon screamed, coughing violently as he spat gray phlegm onto the slush. “I built this place! Harrow’s nothing! He’s an old man rotting in a bed! I ran it! I kept this town alive!”
“You stole from an eighty-four-year-old man with dementia, Gideon,” Arthur Pendelton said smoothly, stepping forward with his thick legal binder open in one gloved hand. “And according to the electronic logs we retrieved from your Salida account twenty minutes ago, you’ve embezzled six hundred and forty thousand dollars over the last forty-eight months.”
Gideon froze, his wild eyes fixing on the lawyer. “You... you can't have those records. That’s private business!”
“It was private,” Arthur corrected him, “until you accused an eight-year-old child of stealing four hundred dollars from a charity drive that—according to the hospital’s records—hasn't received a single deposit from this store in three years.”
A gasp went through the assembled crowd. Mrs. Gable, who had spent the last three hours telling anyone who would listen that the Vale child was a thief, stepped back, her mouth hanging open.
“What?” Mrs. Gable muttered. “Three years?”
“Every dollar dropped into that blue box since 2023,” Caspian said, stepping out of the shadows into the full light of the fire engine’s spot lamps, “went directly into Mr. Pike’s personal gambling account at the casino in Black Hawk. We have the wire transfers, Gideon. We have the timestamps.”
Gideon looked around at the faces of his neighbors—the people he had bullied, the families he had charged illegal fees, the grandmothers he had threatened with eviction notices. There was no sympathy in any of those eyes now; only a cold, hard anger that mirrored the mountain night.
“You...” Gideon spat at Caspian, his voice rising into a ragged shriek. “You came out of nowhere! You don't belong here! You think you can just come into my town with your money and turn everyone against me?”
“You turned them against yourself, Gideon,” Caspian said cold. “The moment you tried to use a child’s charity as a shield for your own petty thefts.”
Officer Vance stepped up, pulled Gideon’s arms behind his back, and snapped the heavy steel handcuffs around his wrists with two sharp clicks.
“Gideon Pike,” Vance said, his voice flat and tired, “you’re under arrest for grand larceny, arson, insurance fraud, and filing a false police report. You have the right to remain silent...”
As the deputies shoved the screaming manager into the back of the patrol car, Officer Vance turned to Caspian. He took off his cap, wiped his sweating forehead despite the cold, and held out his hand.
“Mr. Thorne,” Vance said, “I... I owe that little girl an apology. If you hadn't been standing there...”
“If I hadn't been standing there,” Caspian said, not taking the officer’s hand, “you would have put an innocent eight-year-old in a holding cell tonight because she was poor and Gideon Pike had a tie on.”
May you like
Vance flushed red, looking down at his boots. “You’re right. I was lazy. I took the easy line.”
“Don't apologize to me, Officer,” Caspian said, turning toward his car. “Apologize to Mara Vale. And then help me clean up this town.”
