Chapter 4 - THE LEGAL GRENADE
Marcus Vance’s downtown office didn't look like a place where law was practiced; it looked like a place where corporations came to have their enemies dismantled. The walls were dark glass and polished steel, overlooking the sprawling mountain ranges that bordered the Phoenix valley. Marcus himself was a large man with a thick silver beard, a tailored navy suit, and a total lack of patience for nonsense.
He sat behind his massive desk, looking through the printouts of the social media comments and the photos of the shredded dress I had given him.
"This is textbook intentional infliction of emotional distress, property damage, and civil harassment," Marcus said, his deep voice bouncing off the glass walls. "But more importantly, Daniel, it's incredibly stupid on their part. They left a digital paper trail a mile wide. The twins practically bragged about it in their private group chats, which, thanks to a few cooperative parents of other students who are tired of their behavior, we already have screenshots of."
Hannah sat in the corner of the office, looking out the window at the city below. She had her violin case resting against her leg like a shield. "Marcus... can they really lose their scholarships?"
Marcus looked at her, his expression softening just a fraction. "If the universities find out about a documented history of severe cyberbullying and property damage that resulted in a school suspension? Yes, Hannah. Most academic scholarships have strict character clauses. If a formal civil lawsuit is filed, it becomes public record. The admissions offices will see it."
"Good," I said, sitting opposite him. "File it."
"Daniel, wait," Rebecca's husband, Greg, stepped into the conference room. He had called Marcus’s office an hour ago, begging for a meeting before we filed any paperwork. Greg was a middle manager at an aerospace firm—a man who spent his life trying to keep his head down while his wife ran their household like a military dictatorship. He looked exhausted, his hair uncombed, his tie askew.
"Greg," I said, not standing up to greet him. "You're in the wrong office if you came here to ask for a favor."
"Daniel, please, just hear me out," Greg said, his voice cracking as he took a seat at the far end of the table. He looked at Hannah, his eyes filled with genuine shame. "Hannah, I am so sorry. I didn't know what they did until this morning. If I had known, I would have stopped them. I swear to God I would have."
"But you didn't know, Greg," I said. "Because you've spent seventeen years letting Rebecca raise those girls to think they are royalty and everyone else is dirt. You let them treat Hannah like an outsider since the day Vanessa left."
"I know, I know," Greg pleaded, hands raised in defense. "But a lawsuit? Daniel, it will destroy us financially. The legal fees alone... and if the girls lose their scholarships, we can't afford to send them to college. Rebecca is out of her mind with panic. She’s screaming at everyone. My mother-in-law is having chest pains from the stress. Please, there has to be another way to fix this."
Marcus Vance leaned forward, intertwining his thick fingers on top of his desk. "There is always another way, Mr. Harrington. It’s called a settlement. But the terms of a settlement in a case like this are completely at my client’s discretion. And given the level of malice involved, they won't be cheap."
Greg looked at me, his eyes begging. "What do you want, Daniel? Tell me what it takes to make this stop."
I looked at Hannah. This wasn't my choice anymore. It was hers. The twins had stolen her voice when they destroyed her dress; it was time to give it back to her.
"Hannah," I said gently. "What do you want them to do?"
Hannah turned away from the window. She looked at her uncle Greg—a man who had always been kind to her in passing but had never possessed the courage to stand up for her when it mattered. Then she looked at the table.
"I want an apology," she said, her voice clear and completely devoid of anger. "But not a private one where they whisper it in the kitchen so no one else hears. I want Madison and Chloe to post a public video on their social media pages, tagging the entire school, admitting exactly what they did to my dress and admitting that they lied about me. I want everyone who laughed at me to see who they really are."
Greg winced. "Hannah... that will ruin their social lives completely. They’ll be outcasts for the rest of senior year."
"They wanted me to be an outcast, Uncle Greg," Hannah said, her eyes flashing with a sharp, ancient wisdom that made her look thirty years older than sixteen. "They wanted me to sit in my room on Saturday night while they wore their crowns. They can either tell the truth to the school, or they can tell it to a judge. It's their choice."
Marcus Vance smiled—a dark, predator’s smile. "You heard her, Greg. A full, public retraction and apology video pinned to the top of their profiles for thirty days. In addition, a certified check for five thousand dollars for property damage and emotional distress, paid directly to Hannah’s college fund by five o'clock tomorrow afternoon. If the video isn't up and the check isn't cleared, we file the lawsuit on Wednesday morning."
May you like
Greg stood up slowly, looking like a man who had just been handed a death sentence but knew he had no choice but to carry it out. "I'll talk to Rebecca. I'll make it happen."
As he walked out of the room, I looked at Hannah. She didn't look triumphant; she looked relieved. The weight was beginning to lift, but the real challenge was still ahead. Prom was in five days, and she still didn't have a dress.
