Chapter 6 - The Deposition
The air inside the law office conference room was tense enough to snap a steel blade.
This was the formal deposition before the trial. Sitting across the massive glass table were Dustin, Judith, and their primary attorney, Sterling. Dustin looked exhausted, dark circles under his eyes, his skin pale. Judith, on the other hand, sat straight-backed, wearing a dark navy suit, her eyes cold and dismissive.
Francine sat next to me, her laptop open, flanked by two senior litigation partners from her firm who had joined our legal battle.
"We are on the record," the court reporter announced, adjusting her transcription machine. "Deposition of Judith Miller in the matter of Miller v. Miller."
Francine stood up, placing her hands flat on the glass table. She looked directly at Judith.
"Mrs. Miller, on the afternoon of May 12th, did you utilize an industrial electrical grooming clipper to forcibly remove the hair of your eight-year-old granddaughter, Meadow Miller?"
"I trimmed her hair," Judith answered smoothly, her voice devoid of emotion. "It was unkempt, untidy, and fostering vanity in a child who needed to learn proper decorum."
"Did Meadow scream or cry while you were doing this?" Francine asked.
"Children often cry when forced to submit to discipline," Judith replied coldly. "It is the duty of elders to guide them."
"Did you have the mother’s consent?"
"Claire was incapable of raising a disciplined child," Judith snapped lightly. "Her consent was irrelevant."
"And did you have the father's consent?" Francine pressed, turning her sharp gaze toward Dustin.
Judith didn't flinch. "My son delegated the responsibility of the child's upbringing to me when he asked for my financial support."
Dustin flinched hard, looking down at his hands as if he wished the floor would open up and swallow him whole.
"I see," Francine said smoothly. She pulled out a small electronic tablet and pressed play.
The audio recording of the phone call Judith had made to me two weeks prior filled the glass conference room.
"...I am willing to offer you two hundred thousand dollars... Sign over full sole custody to Dustin... If you refuse, I will ensure that court-ordered evaluations deem you an unfit, unstable mother. I will make sure you never see Meadow again..."
Judith’s lawyer, Sterling, turned pale. "Your Honor—excuse me, counsel—that recording was made without my client’s explicit consent!"
"Indiana is a one-party consent state for audio recording, Mr. Sterling," Francine countered, her voice dropping like an anvil. "Your client attempted to bribe and extort my client to secure illegal custody of a child she physically abused."
Judith’s facade finally shattered. She slammed her hand down on the glass table, her pearl necklace rattling against her neck. "She is a weak, worthless girl who ruined my son’s life! I built that family! I paid for their house! I paid for his business! I have every right to decide how my granddaughter is raised!"
"Mom, stop!" Dustin suddenly yelled, slamming his own hands onto the table.
The room went dead silent. Everyone turned to look at Dustin.
Tears were streaming down Dustin's face, his eyes wide with a mixture of terror and profound horror. He looked at Judith as if seeing her clearly for the very first time.
"Dustin, sit down and keep quiet," Judith commanded, her voice dropping into that familiar, chilling tone of total authority.
"No!" Dustin shouted, his voice cracking. "No, Mom! Shut up! Just shut up!"
He turned to look at me, his chest heaving. "Claire... oh God, Claire... what have we done?"
"Dustin, you will ruin everything!" Judith barked, standing up to grab his arm.
Dustin violently shoved her hand away. "You told me it was just a haircut! You told me Claire was going crazy! You tricked me into signing those financial papers! You’ve been controlling my whole life, and I let you hurt my own daughter!"
"Mr. Miller, calm down," Sterling urged, trying to regain control of his client.
May you like
"I’m done!" Dustin cried out, burying his face in his hands, weeping openly in front of the court reporter and attorneys. "I’m done lying for you, Mom. I’m done letting you destroy my family."
I sat across the table, watching the collapse of the man I had once loved. There was no joy in watching his destruction—only a profound, tragic sadness for the little girl who had lost her father long before the clippers ever touched her hair.
