Chapter 8 - The Trial of the Compassionate
For three hours, Harrison Vance grilled Benjamin on the stand. He questioned his motives, his financial interest in the Platte County land, and his sudden "obsession" with the Hale family.
"Mr. Cross," Vance said, leaning against the jury box. "You are a man who deals in concrete numbers. You don't make decisions based on emotion. Yet you expect this jury to believe that you broke open a secured commercial property at four in the morning simply because of a 'feeling'?"
"I didn't do it because of a feeling, Mr. Vance," Benjamin said, his voice echoing clearly through the silent courtroom. "I did it because I was an eight-year-old boy once. And I know exactly what it sounds like when a child is telling the truth and the whole world is choosing to lie."
"A touching sentiment," Vance sneered. "But the law relies on hard evidence, not childhood nostalgia. You have no proof that my client was the one who locked that dumpster. The recording you provided was found inside a toy, completely unsecured, accessible to anyone—including a boy who might have been coached by a corporate predator looking for a land grab."
A murmur ran through the courtroom. Derek’s smile widened.
"The recording speaks for itself, Mr. Vance," Benjamin said calmly.
"Does it?" Vance countered. "In the state of Missouri, a recording made without the consent of all parties is inadmissible in a civil property dispute. And in a criminal court, without expert validation of the acoustic footprint, it can be argued that this voice was generated or manipulated."
The judge cleared his throat. "Mr. Vance, the court has already ruled the audio admissible due to the exigent circumstances involving an active kidnapping."
"But the jury hasn't heard the full context, Your Honor," Vance said, turning to the box. "We believe the voice on that tape isn't Derek Hale at all. We believe it's a structural imitation designed to frame him."
The district attorney stood up. "Your Honor, this is absurd. The prosecution calls our next witness to resolve any doubt about what happened in that service lane."
May you like
The doors at the back of the courtroom opened.
Rachel Hale walked in. She was pale, leaning slightly on a cane, but her eyes were fixed on Derek with a ferocity that made the defense attorney step back.
