Chapter 2 - The White Shape in the Snow
The wind howling off Lake Michigan didn’t just carry the cold; it carried a physical weight that pressed against Liam’s chest as he stared down from the third-story balcony.
The white shape lying motionless beside the frozen oak tree below looked tiny from this height. It was the white knit sweater Nora had been wearing when he locked her out. The snow around it was undisturbed, save for the dark, jagged shadow cast by the branches.
"Nora!" Liam’s voice tore from his throat, thin and cracked, instantly swallowed by the November wind.
He didn’t wait for the elevator. He bolted through the living room, his bare feet sliding on the hardwood, slamming his shoulder into the front door frame as he broke out into the carpeted hallway. Behind him, the guest room door creaked open. Gwen stood there, rubbing her eyes, her face a mask of mild annoyance that rapidly shifted to sharp calculation as she saw her brother running like a madman.
"Liam? What is it? What's going on?" she called out, but he was already flying down the concrete stairwell, three steps at a time.
His bare feet hit the freezing asphalt of the parking lot. The cold was a physical shock, biting into his skin, but he didn't feel it. He ran around the side of the building, his breath coming in ragged, painful gasps, his eyes locked on the base of the oak tree.
He threw himself into the snowbank, his hands frantically digging, reaching for the white fabric.
"Nora! Nora, I’m so sorry, please—"
He pulled the sweater up.
It was empty.
Liam froze, his hands trembling as he held the heavy, damp wool. It was soaked through, not with fresh snow, but with a strange, dark river water that smelled faintly of mud and decaying leaves. Tucked inside the collar of the sweater, pinned with a rusted safety pin, was a small, waterlogged piece of heavy cardstock.
Through the blurred, icy tears in his eyes, Liam stared at the elegant, neat handwriting of his wife. The ink had bled, but the words were still terrifyingly legible:
Liam,
You believed her. You always believed her. The $8,000 wasn't a theft. It was the price of your mother's dignity, and the key to the cellar where Gwen keeps her secrets. Look at the Grand River, Liam. That's where the truth drowns. Don't look for me. You locked the door. I just chose to keep it locked.
"No," Liam whispered, clutching the wet sweater to his chest. "No, no, no..."
"Liam!" Gwen’s voice was closer now. She had put on her winter coat and boots, walking carefully across the icy grass. She stopped a few feet away, her eyes dropping to the wet sweater in his arms, and then to the cardstock in his hand. A sudden, violent flicker of panic crossed her face before she quickly masked it with an expression of maternal pity.
"Oh, Liam... she ran away," Gwen said softly, reaching out to touch his shoulder. "She left her clothes to scare you. It’s a trick. She’s trying to make you feel guilty so you won't ask about the stolen money. Come inside, you’re freezing."
Liam looked up at his sister. For the first time in his life, the blind trust he had placed in her felt like a heavy, suffocating noose. He looked at the wet trail on the balcony, the river water on the sweater, and the note in his hand.
May you like
"How did you know she was on the phone, Gwen?" Liam asked, his voice dead and hollow. "You said you heard her. But Nora's mother has been in an assisted living facility in Petoskey—the one you manage—for the last two years. She hasn't been able to speak since her stroke."
Gwen's hand on his shoulder went completely rigid.
